Alistair vs Trixie Plushie: Which Doomlings Character to Cuddle
By Doomlings | A Delightful Card Game For The End of the World | Published: 2026-10-28
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Alistair and Trixie Doomlings plushies—same ultra-squeezable build, different characters. Find out which one fits your cuddle style and collection.
Quick answer
Both Alistair and Trixie share the same ultra-squeezable 10-inch velvet-and-memory-foam build, so your choice comes down to which character you want to cuddle. Alistair costs a dollar more but is the better pick if you favor a classic, mysterious vibe; Trixie is your go-to for a playful, colorful companion at a slightly lower price.
Same plush, different personality
Both Alistair and Trixie are constructed with the same luxurious stretchable velvet exterior and super-soft memory foam filling, so you get identical softness and durability regardless of which you pick. The only differences are the character design and the price tag.
Alistair brings a darker, more mysterious aesthetic that fits the Doomlings theme of playful doom. Trixie, on the other hand, leans into bright, whimsical colors that feel more lighthearted. Neither is better—they just appeal to different tastes.
Price difference worth noting
Alistair is listed at $17.99 (originally $24.99), while Trixie costs $16.49 (originally $24.99). That’s a $1.50 difference for the same plush quality. If budget is tight, Trixie gives you the same cuddle experience for a little less. But if you connect more with Alistair’s design, the extra dollar is negligible.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Character design: Alistair has a darker, more mysterious look; Trixie is bright and playful.
- Price: Alistair: $17.99 (retail $24.99). Trixie: $16.49 (retail $24.99).
- Build quality: Identical 10-inch size, velvet exterior, memory foam fill, and durability. Since the plush construction is the same, the trade-off is purely aesthetic and financial.
Product facts at a glance
- Trixie Plushie: Trixie Plushie is a 10-inch plush with a stretchable velvet exterior and memory foam filling. This means Trixie is ultra-squeezable and retains its shape after hugging, making it a durable travel companion.
Trixie Plushie - Alistair Plushie: Alistair Plushie is a 10-inch plush with the same stretchable velvet exterior and memory foam filling. Alistair offers the same plush quality and durability, so your choice is purely about character preference and price.
Alistair Plushie
Which one should you choose?
Best for
- Fans of darker, moodier character designs who don't mind paying a dollar more.
- Collectors who want a classic Doomlings villain-style plush.
Not for
- Shoppers on a strict budget who still want the same plush quality—Trixie is cheaper.
- Those who prefer bright, cheerful plushies—Alistair’s design may feel too somber.
